Critical Finance Review > Vol 7 > Issue

Are Competitive Banking Systems Really Stable?

Samangi Bandaranayake, University of Canterbury, New Zealand, Kuntal Das, University of Canterbury, New Zealand, W. Robert Reed, University of Canterbury, New Zealand,
Suggested Citation
Samangi Bandaranayake, Kuntal Das and W. Robert Reed (2019), "Are Competitive Banking Systems Really Stable?", Critical Finance Review: Vol. 7: No. .

Forthcoming: 31 Mar 2019
© 2018 S. Bandaranayake, K. Das, and W. R. Reed
Systemic riskBank competitionConcentrationH-statisticReplication

Article Help


Download article
In this article:
1. Introduction
2. Reproduction of SCW’s Key Results
3. Updating the Control Variables
4. ROBUSTNESS CHECK 1: Reestimation of Models Using Current Vintage Data
5. ROBUSTNESS CHECK 2: Extending the Time Period
6. ROBUSTNESS CHECK 3: Using a Different Measure of Financial Stability
7. Investigating Alternative Measures of Competition
8. Conclusion
Appendix: Indexes Used for Computing Alpha on Individual Mutual Funds


This study replicates Schaeck et al. (2009), henceforth SCW. SCW conclude that (i) concentration and competition (as measured by Panzar and Rosse’s H-statistic) represent two separate dimensions of the banking sector, with (ii) greater competition being associated with greater financial stability. Using their data, we are able to exactly reproduce their original results. However, when we use current vintage data for the variables in their dataset, from both the same and alternative data sources, we find that H-statistic fails to attain significance at the 5% level. We obtain this result even though we use the same variables, estimation, and sample as SCW—just with more recent data instead of the earlier (later revised) numbers provided by the data vendors. Additional tests, such as expanding the timeframe from 1980–2005 to 1980–2011, employing more recent data for H-statistic and concentration, or using the z-score as an alternative measure of financial distress, further confirm this result. Further, not only are the estimates statistically insignificant, but they are economically insignificant, with small effect magnitudes. Our paper suggests that competition may not positively contribute to financial stability after all.